"Highest and Best Use" and its Relationship with Texas Real Property Tax Law

In Texas, the concept of "highest and best use" does not directly govern property tax assessments for most properties. This is a common misunderstanding rooted in appraisal theory for market value. Under the Texas Constitution and Tax Code, properties are generally appraised at their market value, which is defined as the price a willing buyer would pay a willing seller. The key legal principle, however, is that for most properties, this market value assessment is based on the current use of the property, not a hypothetical "highest and best use" that might imply a more intensive or valuable future use.

For instance, a parcel of land in a developing area that is currently used as a family residence would typically be assessed based on its value as residential property, not its potential value as a future commercial development, even if the latter would yield a higher market price. The appraisal district's responsibility is to determine the market value based on the property's existing condition and use, ensuring a fair and uniform tax burden.

A notable exception to this rule is properties designated for specific "open-space" or "agricultural" uses. These properties receive special appraisal and are taxed based on their productive value for agriculture or timber production, which is significantly lower than their market value would be if they were appraised for general market purposes. This is a policy mechanism to preserve agricultural lands and prevent owners from being taxed out of business by urban encroachment.

To challenge an appraisal or understand how your property is valued, the Texas Tax Code outlines a formal process. Property owners receive a notice of appraised value annually and have the right to protest the appraisal to their local appraisal review board (ARB). The burden is generally on the appraisal district to prove the market value assertion. Property owners can find resources and guidance from the Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts website and their local appraisal district websites for specific procedures and deadlines for filing a protest. Just as importantly, property owners can hire tax consultants and attorneys to litigate these cases.

While "highest and best use" is a foundational appraisal concept, Texas law prioritizes current use appraisal for most properties to maintain fairness in taxation, with special provisions for agricultural land use. Understanding how Texas law defines market value for taxation, as distinct from general appraisal theory, is crucial for property owners seeking to ensure fair and accurate tax assessments.

Need to learn more? Get in touch.